Case Snapshot: Botella (2026)
26 April 2026 · Gavin Quayle, Principal
Key points
- This case snapshot examines the decision by DP Lazanas in the Australian Review Tribunal ("ART") in Botella and Commissioner of Taxation (Taxation and business) [2026] ARTA 604 (16 April 2026).
- The ART has confirmed that a pro-forma Div 7A loan agreement embedded in a company's constitution does not satisfy the s109N "wholly in writing" requirement. Advances made by conduct before a written agreement is executed will not meet the complying loan requirement in section 109N. Get the paperwork done before the money moves.
- Botella is another s177E win for the Commissioner, confirming that the six CPH dividend stripping characteristics apply to wholly internal restructures with no external stripper. Private groups contemplating - or that have already implemented - internal restructures involving a reduction in retained profits need to seriously consider their dividend stripping exposure.
- The P-note mechanics in Botella were central to how the scheme operated and how it ultimately unravelled. Advisers should be alert to promissory note structures in related party arrangements - they are firmly in the Commissioner's line of sight
To access a PDF copy of this article, please click this link.
| Step | Tax outcome |
|---|---|
| 1. Interposition: New HoldCo incorporated and interposed between Mr Botella and OpCo via scrip transfer. HoldCo share capital set equal to OpCo’s retained earnings (~A$1m). | Subdiv 122-A tax free exchange |
| 2. Dividend: OpCo declares ~A$1m fully franked dividend to New HoldCo, satisfied by issuing a promissory note for the dividend amount. | No tax. |
| 3. New Loan: New HoldCo endorses the promissory note to Mr Botella as a new loan, governed by a written, unsecured, interest-free, at-call facility agreement. | No tax. |
| 4. Collapse Old Loan: Mr Botella endorses the promissory note back to OpCo, extinguishing his pre-existing shareholder loan account with OpCo. | No tax. Div 7A loan collapsed. |
Hilltop observations
- Div 7A complying loan agreements: Further to the SNA Group FFC decision, arrangements by conduct are under scrutiny again. This time dealing with the “complying Div 7A loan agreement” rules in s109N. Broadly, the Tribunal agreed with the Commissioner that the loan must be wholly in writing before the loan is made – not after, as was the purported effect of OpCo’s constitution deeming a loan of advances already made.
- Dividend stripping: Botella is another s 177E win for the Commissioner, confirming that the six CPH characteristics can apply to wholly internal restructures with no external stripper. Whilst the Botella saga may be ongoing, the key takeaway for private groups is to seriously consider their 177E position if they are contemplating (or have implemented) internal restructures accompanied by a reduction of retained profits.
- Distributable surplus: The Tribunal considered whether certain items were included in the distributable surplus calculation however these findings appear uncontroversial.
- Final remark: This case should serve as a reminder for advisers to be alert, in particular to P-note mechanics in related party arrangements (as the P-notes in Botella were central to how the scheme operated).
Get in touch
If this article has raised questions relevant to your situation, we would be glad to hear from you. Email info@hilltoptax.com.au or call 0434 487 867. All enquiries are handled personally by Gavin Quayle, Principal.
Disclaimer. The information contained in this communication is general in nature and does not constitute advice. This document is current as at the date of publication as shown in the header banner and will not be updated. The information contained in this communication should not be relied on. Hilltop Tax Advisory disclaims all responsibility and liability arising from any party relying on the information contained in this communication, and before acting on any of this information you should seek professional advice.
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.