The trust minimum tax: the draft law is out

The trust minimum tax: the draft law is out

· Gavin Quayle, Principal

Update · November 2026

The trust minimum tax Bill is now before the Senate. Read what the Senate Bill means for family trusts and bucket companies.

Treasury released the exposure draft legislation for the 30% minimum tax on discretionary trusts on Thursday, 3 September. Once enacted, trustees will pay 30% tax on trust income from 1 July 2028, and bucket companies will be largely unviable. The planning window is much shorter than that, and the first decisions need to be made well before then.

How we got here

The measure was announced by Treasurer Chalmers in the 2026-27 Federal Budget on 12 May 2026. Treasury then undertook a round of consultation which closed on 31 July 2026. Hilltop provided a submission to Treasury, however consultation submissions have not yet been made public.

The exposure draft has now been released in three key parts:

  • the core amendments to the Tax Acts to implement the 30% minimum tax,
  • a restructure rollover, and
  • an elective regime falling outside of the 30% minimum tax.

Of the three, only the elective regime was not previously announced. You can access Treasurer Chalmers' announcement here, and the exposure draft materials here. Consultation closes on 18 September 2026.

The problem with the policy

The measure treats discretionary trusts as if they are pure tax shelters, and that tax advantages are the only reason for their existence in business and family structures. This is far from the case. And the incidence of the tax would fall most heavily on ordinary families rather than the arrangements it was aimed at.

As part of Treasury's first round of consultation, Hilltop made a submission with 24 recommendations. Several of the themes we pressed have made it into the draft. As expected, many did not. The elective regime represents the most significant policy concession following consultation, which provides a narrow corridor for in-scope discretionary trusts (and eligible bucket companies) to fall outside of the minimum tax rules. Key elements of this corridor remain uncertain, including key interpretative issues within the draft law, as well as interaction issues with trust law.

Additionally, whilst not featured in the law, Treasurer Chalmers' announcement accompanying the draft law stated that unpaid present entitlements ("UPEs") will be codified into Division 7A - reversing the outcome in Bendel. This is a significant announcement, and pre-2009 UPEs may lose their grandfathered status.

What the draft law does

Very broadly, almost every discretionary trust is expected to fall within scope of the minimum tax. You then have three paths:

  • Path 1 - Do nothing
  • Path 2 - Restructure out
  • Path 3 - Elect into the excluded regime

We explain each path below on the basis of our current understanding of the draft law for the purpose of illustrating indicative tax outcomes. Please note the measures may be subject to change as part of the consultation process and (subsequent) legislative process.

Path 1: Do nothing

From 1 July 2028, the trustee would be assessed and liable to pay tax at 30% on the trust's net income. Beneficiaries who are not companies receive a non-refundable 30% offset so:

  • High-income earner beneficiaries on the top marginal rate are broadly no worse off.
  • Middle-income earner beneficiaries are also broadly no worse off, provided their income tax bill is at least 30% of the distribution.
  • Low-income earner beneficiaries whose effective tax rates are less than 30% will be worse off (such as distributions to an adult beneficiary whose other taxable income is less than about $32,500).

Corporate beneficiaries (i.e. bucket companies) are the big losers - with effective tax rates of up to 70% of the amount distributed once the income is paid out to shareholders. As a consequence, bucket companies are effectively unviable if this measure is enacted in its current form, unless they qualify for, and the trust opts into, the excluded regime discussed below.

The measure will also have important cash-flow consequences for trustees in meeting their tax liability.

On the bright side, there are some helpful exclusions - taxable primary production income, certain minor beneficiary income, certain charitable distributions and non-resident withholding payments.

Path 2: Restructure out

As originally announced, the draft law includes tax deferral (i.e. "rollover relief") for restructuring assets out of a discretionary structure between 1 July 2027 and 30 June 2030. Importantly, the deferral operates on an "all or nothing" basis - every asset of the trust must move, or the rollover fails for all of them. The transferee cannot be another discretionary trust, a super fund or an exempt entity, and if material discretionary elements reappear within four years of transfer the relief is lost.

Importantly, on our reading, the restructure only applies to discretionary trusts which have made a family trust election. Non-family trusts would be included conditional on the Minister determining the requirements by legislative instrument. This is a feature of the Government's law-making approach we have observed in the capital gains tax changes: to rush the law onto the statute books and defer critical elements of its operation until later on and outside of the legislative process.

You will appreciate that rollover relief is Commonwealth relief only. If your trust holds land or other dutiable property, transfer duty may apply at full rates, and in NSW that is often the largest single number in the exercise. Duty imposition is likely the single biggest factor which rules out this path for many groups.

Path 3: Elect into the excluded regime

The third path is freshly announced as part of the release of the draft law. This path provides, broadly, an elective "excluded regime" to take trusts outside the minimum tax rules. In our view this regime reflects a rushed and half-considered measure designed to quieten stakeholder concerns about the minimum tax and restructure issues. This is because:

  • it is exceptionally narrow in its qualifying criteria and scope of operation,
  • it will impose onerous compliance costs on taxpayers,
  • it will suffer from the same types of unintentional non-compliance risks we have seen with family trust elections,
  • it may impair asset protection objectives,
  • it may still trigger stamp duty (even though the Government has said this regime should not)
  • it may be out of step with the law of trusts.

We would therefore not expect the excluded regime to be adopted by many taxpayers as is currently drafted.

Very broadly, how it works is that the trustee elects for the trust to be an "excluded election trust", which takes it outside the minimum tax entirely and preserves distributions to certain "eligible" bucket companies without suffering double tax outcomes. To elect in, the trustee must effectively "fix" each beneficiary and their percentage share of both income and capital, in equal proportions, totalling 100%, and must then distribute in exactly those proportions every year. That is, discretion is gone. The discretionary trust's distributions would effectively behave like a fixed trust.

A corporate beneficiary only qualifies if it is an "eligible company" with no material discretionary elements affecting members' rights. By our reading, most standard constitutions would not meet that as they stand. Also, nominated beneficiaries must have been capable of benefiting on 1 July 2028, so a grandchild born later cannot be added, except on the death of a nominated beneficiary whose estate they take under. The nomination can only be varied on death or a family law order. The revocation triggers are broad (such as a share in the bucket company changing hands for ordinary commercial reasons), which would result in "booting" the taxpayer out of the regime forever, imposing a full-year 47% tax to the trustee on the entire yearly net income, and then being subject to the minimum tax for future years.

Accordingly, as drafted, we consider very few discretionary trusts (and even fewer corporate beneficiaries) would elect into this new regime.

What we think of the draft law

We consider that:

  • The minimum tax is broadly consistent with what was announced in the May Budget and the Treasury Consultation Paper. That is, outside of the elective regime, bucket companies will be effectively "killed off" with effective tax-rates on income flowing-through these companies of up to 70%. And low-income earners will lose access to their lower-than-30% tax rate. In our view, the discretionary trust minimum tax is a punitive measure which should not be enacted in its current form.
  • The rollover regime for restructures may be attractive for those trusts with family trust elections in place, where the trust does not have dutiable property, where there are no collateral legal or practical obstacles to the restructure, and where an alternative structure is commercially suitable. Ultimately there may be very few trusts that meet these requirements to make this path a feasible solution.
  • The elective regime is too narrow in scope, too brittle in operative effect and too uncertain in collateral outcomes. In our view, very few taxpayers will elect into this regime as presently drafted.

Further, consistent with the capital gains tax measures, too much detail sits in legislative instruments that do not exist yet. Most important are the continuity requirements for non-family trusts and the matters that determine whether discretionary elements are "material". That last test impacts a number of important aspects of the draft law and significantly impairs any planning being done with confidence.

Where the government may move

As part of the consultation process, we expect some elements of the draft law to be revisited, such as clarifying key elements currently subject to legislative instruments as well as widening access to both path 2 and path 3. However, consistent with the Government's responses to the capital gains tax changes, we would not expect any substantial relief or paring-back of the rules as presently drafted. We also expect further legislation on interaction issues and administration/reporting rules.

What to do now

If you have not already considered this, either for yourself or your clients (as relevant), we would suggest assessing the impact of these measures to model potential tax outcomes and consider whether path 2 or path 3 may be feasible options in yours or your clients' circumstances. Bearing in mind the draft law remains subject to change as it continues to be subject to consultation as well as the subsequent legislative process.

We are working through client groups over the coming months. If you would like to discuss how these measures may impact you or your clients, please book a time below.

Key dates

18 September 2026 Submissions close to Treasury
1 July 2027 Restructure rollover opens [draft law]
1 July 2028 Minimum tax starts and the election window opens [draft law]
30 June 2029 Election window closes for June balancers [draft law]
30 June 2030 Restructure rollover closes [draft law]

Book a call

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. The information contained in this article is general in nature and does not constitute advice. This article is current as at the date of publication and will not be updated. The information contained in it should not be relied on. Hilltop Tax Advisory disclaims all responsibility and liability arising from any party relying on the information contained in this article. Before acting on any of the information contained in this article you should seek professional advice.